Monday, June 2, 2025

NEA Pitch Feedback

 Ms Casson’s Feedback:

Magazine:Fatale

Clear and confident presentations.

Get your terminology right - long shot. 

Jennifer Lopez - would she appeal to target audience? She is 55!

Your ideas seem to be a bit older for the target audience.

Like the Nigerian model aesthetic idea and the strong woman idea.

Nice website ideas-glad you have thought of the 30seconds.

Stick with the strong woman idea but give it a younger twist.


Class Mate’s Feedback:

1. Reconsider. Is the theme/aesthetic is suitable, idea is nice but maybe not 16-25, or something teens would wear

2. 

- Good audience research to ensure you can reflect interests 

- Like the name!! - but beware of the aesthetic appealing to the audience age

- Love the idea of your 2nd edition and the inclusion of culture

- Models match vibes and well chosen

- Sports interview compliments the represented ideology 

3. 

- Like the idea of  magazine connecting with all 16-25 year olds - maybe use intertextuality for this?

- Maybe consider if the theme works for 16-25 year olds

-  the 2nd edition is really good - wold appeal to target audience + is good idea

4.

- Good masthead 

- I like the contrast of editions

- Good website ideas

5. I think the suit would work with more luxurious/ financial theming - I think the moodboard still applies

6.

- Try and be more consistent throughout

- Make sure you have a clear picture of the theme 

7.

- Working masthead works well with mood board - tone it down slightly for target audience - appeal to 16-25 year olds

- Idea for first cover works with the theme 

- I like use of natural and editorial backgrounds

- sports feature works well with aims of magazine 

8. 

- Target demographic - age appropriate 

- Like the female magazine

- Not sure the location fits the theme 

- Like the strong women 

9.

- Try and bee more consistent throughout 

- Make sure you have a clear picture of the theme 

10.

- Good name choice 

- Love the idea for the second edition 

- Helayna sitting on car would work well

11.  The name works but shift your aesthetic to be more appropriate for the age group 

12. 

- Add audience profile wit a specific person

- Alter first mood board - younger, more suitable 

13. 

- I like the name ‘fatale’- very powerful - and now this theme is reflected throughout 

- Warm orange tones will look great!

  

NEA Pitch Feedback

 Ms Casson’s Feedback: Magazine:Fatale Clear and confident presentations. Get your terminology right - long shot.  Jennifer Lopez - would sh...